I am an international student in the US and as soon as I arrived in the college one of my main concerns along the list was finding a good quality toilet paper. It is no secret that in public institutions generally (at least from my experience) toilet paper is of the lowest quality. I used to use Selpak in Armenia, which is of a great quality and tried to find something as close to that brand as possible since that brand itself doesn't exist in the US.
My search began from the shops but since I did not have a lot of time, I stopped after finding something that was more or less ok, which was Cottonelle Cleancare. It was pretty soft and nice to touch but did not have the extra layer of special substance on the top that makes it smooth and ripple free.
Soon, when I learned about Amazon Prime Pantry I decided to order several toilet papers and try out which one would work best. From the ones I had my top 3 were:
1. Cottonelle Ultra Comfortcare.
2. Charmin Ultra Strong.
3. Cottonelle Cleancare.
Now a bit more details about all of these.
1. Cottonelle Ultra Comfortcare.
Cost: 1.03/count
Out of all the American toilet papers I have so far tried, this particular one is the best in terms of being soft and string and ripple free which are the main things I look for in the toilet paper, there is definitely a room for improvement and I would strongly recommend the manufacturers to order some of the Selpak toilet papers from Europe and also maybe some of the tissue papers and to develop in both directions. This is the closest to best I have so far found.
2. Charmin Ultra Strong.
Cost: 1.10 /count
As opposed to its name, it is weaker than you would expect. It is relatively ripple free, but has the same problems as Cottonelle Ultra Comfortcare. Last a little bit less then Cottonelle Ultra Comfortcare. It is a fine toilet paper, with more room for improvement.
3. Cottonelle Cleancare
Cost: 0.58/count
This is the toilet paper that I managed to use for the longest since out of my first sample of toilet papers it turned out to work the best. Lasts about the same as Charmin Ultra Strong, though it is a bit stronger but more ripply.
Overall all these are fine to use, hopefully at least one of them will improve to meet my expectations properly and make me really happy and I will consume since then till the rest of my stay that specific one. For now definitely recommend Cottonelle Ultra ComfortCare, but will update if my opinion changes.
There is a newer version of this item:
Cottonelle Ultra ComfortCare Toilet Paper, Soft Biodegradable Bath Tissue, Septic-Safe, 36 Family Rolls
$59.99 ($0.82 / 100 Sheets)
(21,895)
In Stock
$59.99 ($0.82 / 100 Sheets)
(21,895)
In Stock
Similar items that may deliver to you quickly
Page 1 of 1 Start overPage 1 of 1
Climate Pledge FriendlyProducts with trusted sustainability certification(s). Learn morePRODUCT CERTIFICATION (1)
The Forest Stewardship Council certified products support responsible forestry, helping keep forests healthy for future generations.
Climate Pledge FriendlyProducts with trusted sustainability certification(s). Learn morePRODUCT CERTIFICATION (1)
The Forest Stewardship Council certified products support responsible forestry, helping keep forests healthy for future generations.
Climate Pledge FriendlyProducts with trusted sustainability certification(s). Learn morePRODUCT CERTIFICATION (1)
The Forest Stewardship Council certified products support responsible forestry, helping keep forests healthy for future generations.
Climate Pledge FriendlyProducts with trusted sustainability certification(s). Learn morePRODUCT CERTIFICATION (1)
The Forest Stewardship Council certified products support responsible forestry, helping keep forests healthy for future generations.
Climate Pledge FriendlyProducts with trusted sustainability certification(s). Learn morePRODUCT CERTIFICATION (1)
The Forest Stewardship Council certified products support responsible forestry, helping keep forests healthy for future generations.
Compare with similar items
This Item  Cottonelle Ultra Comfort Care Family Roll Toilet Paper, Bath Tissue, 36 Toilet Paper Rolls |  |  |  |  |  | |
| Price | — | -11% $39.00 List: $43.99 | -5% $27.97 List: $29.49 | $11.09 | $55.96 | $59.00 |
| Price Per Unit | — | $0.45 / 100 Sheets | $0.34 / 100 Sheets | $0.51 / 100 Sheets | $0.69 / 100 Sheets | $24.18 / 100 Sheets |
| Delivery | — | Get it May 6 - 8 | Get it as soon as Wednesday, May 1 | Get it as soon as Wednesday, May 1 | Get it Apr 29 - May 1 | Get it as soon as Wednesday, May 1 |
| Customer Ratings | ||||||
| Absorbency | ||||||
| Softness | ||||||
| Value for money | ||||||
| Sold By | — | Media A | Amazon.com | Amazon.com | flipcost | Liberty Office Supplies |
| roll quantity | 36 | 30 | 32 | — | — | 36 |
| sheet count | 36 | 8640 | 8160 | 2196 | 8160 | 244 |
| size | 36 Count (Pack of 1) | 30 Count | 8160 sheet (Pack of 1) | 244 sheet (Pack of 9) | 12 Count (Pack of 4) | 1 roll (Pack of 36) |
| material | Paper | Paper | Paper | Paper | Paper | Paper |
| ply | 2-Ply | 2-Ply | 3-Ply | 2-Ply | 2-Ply | 2-Ply |
| weight | 8.17 pounds | 11 pounds | 11.94 pounds | — | — | — |
| special feature | Flushable | Ultra Soft, Clog Free, Septic Safe | Ultra Soft, Absorbent, Septic Safe, 3-ply | Flushable | Absorbent | Ultra Soft |
Reviews with images
Comparative review for toilet papers in the US
I am an international student in the US and as soon as I arrived in the college one of my main concerns along the list was finding a good quality toilet paper. It is no secret that in public institutions generally (at least from my experience) toilet paper is of the lowest quality. I used to use Selpak in Armenia, which is of a great quality and tried to find something as close to that brand as possible since that brand itself doesn't exist in the US.My search began from the shops but since I did not have a lot of time, I stopped after finding something that was more or less ok, which was Cottonelle Cleancare. It was pretty soft and nice to touch but did not have the extra layer of special substance on the top that makes it smooth and ripple free.Soon, when I learned about Amazon Prime Pantry I decided to order several toilet papers and try out which one would work best. From the ones I had my top 3 were:1. Cottonelle Ultra Comfortcare.2. Charmin Ultra Strong.3. Cottonelle Cleancare.Now a bit more details about all of these.1. Cottonelle Ultra Comfortcare.Cost: 1.03/countOut of all the American toilet papers I have so far tried, this particular one is the best in terms of being soft and string and ripple free which are the main things I look for in the toilet paper, there is definitely a room for improvement and I would strongly recommend the manufacturers to order some of the Selpak toilet papers from Europe and also maybe some of the tissue papers and to develop in both directions. This is the closest to best I have so far found.2. Charmin Ultra Strong.Cost: 1.10 /countAs opposed to its name, it is weaker than you would expect. It is relatively ripple free, but has the same problems as Cottonelle Ultra Comfortcare. Last a little bit less then Cottonelle Ultra Comfortcare. It is a fine toilet paper, with more room for improvement.3. Cottonelle CleancareCost: 0.58/countThis is the toilet paper that I managed to use for the longest since out of my first sample of toilet papers it turned out to work the best. Lasts about the same as Charmin Ultra Strong, though it is a bit stronger but more ripply.Overall all these are fine to use, hopefully at least one of them will improve to meet my expectations properly and make me really happy and I will consume since then till the rest of my stay that specific one. For now definitely recommend Cottonelle Ultra ComfortCare, but will update if my opinion changes.
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
Reviewed in the United States on September 30, 2017
My search began from the shops but since I did not have a lot of time, I stopped after finding something that was more or less ok, which was Cottonelle Cleancare. It was pretty soft and nice to touch but did not have the extra layer of special substance on the top that makes it smooth and ripple free.
Soon, when I learned about Amazon Prime Pantry I decided to order several toilet papers and try out which one would work best. From the ones I had my top 3 were:
1. Cottonelle Ultra Comfortcare.
2. Charmin Ultra Strong.
3. Cottonelle Cleancare.
Now a bit more details about all of these.
1. Cottonelle Ultra Comfortcare.
Cost: 1.03/count
Out of all the American toilet papers I have so far tried, this particular one is the best in terms of being soft and string and ripple free which are the main things I look for in the toilet paper, there is definitely a room for improvement and I would strongly recommend the manufacturers to order some of the Selpak toilet papers from Europe and also maybe some of the tissue papers and to develop in both directions. This is the closest to best I have so far found.
2. Charmin Ultra Strong.
Cost: 1.10 /count
As opposed to its name, it is weaker than you would expect. It is relatively ripple free, but has the same problems as Cottonelle Ultra Comfortcare. Last a little bit less then Cottonelle Ultra Comfortcare. It is a fine toilet paper, with more room for improvement.
3. Cottonelle Cleancare
Cost: 0.58/count
This is the toilet paper that I managed to use for the longest since out of my first sample of toilet papers it turned out to work the best. Lasts about the same as Charmin Ultra Strong, though it is a bit stronger but more ripply.
Overall all these are fine to use, hopefully at least one of them will improve to meet my expectations properly and make me really happy and I will consume since then till the rest of my stay that specific one. For now definitely recommend Cottonelle Ultra ComfortCare, but will update if my opinion changes.
Size: 9 Count (Pack of 1)Verified Purchase
Comparative review for toilet papers in the US
Reviewed in the United States on September 30, 2017
I am an international student in the US and as soon as I arrived in the college one of my main concerns along the list was finding a good quality toilet paper. It is no secret that in public institutions generally (at least from my experience) toilet paper is of the lowest quality. I used to use Selpak in Armenia, which is of a great quality and tried to find something as close to that brand as possible since that brand itself doesn't exist in the US.Reviewed in the United States on September 30, 2017
My search began from the shops but since I did not have a lot of time, I stopped after finding something that was more or less ok, which was Cottonelle Cleancare. It was pretty soft and nice to touch but did not have the extra layer of special substance on the top that makes it smooth and ripple free.
Soon, when I learned about Amazon Prime Pantry I decided to order several toilet papers and try out which one would work best. From the ones I had my top 3 were:
1. Cottonelle Ultra Comfortcare.
2. Charmin Ultra Strong.
3. Cottonelle Cleancare.
Now a bit more details about all of these.
1. Cottonelle Ultra Comfortcare.
Cost: 1.03/count
Out of all the American toilet papers I have so far tried, this particular one is the best in terms of being soft and string and ripple free which are the main things I look for in the toilet paper, there is definitely a room for improvement and I would strongly recommend the manufacturers to order some of the Selpak toilet papers from Europe and also maybe some of the tissue papers and to develop in both directions. This is the closest to best I have so far found.
2. Charmin Ultra Strong.
Cost: 1.10 /count
As opposed to its name, it is weaker than you would expect. It is relatively ripple free, but has the same problems as Cottonelle Ultra Comfortcare. Last a little bit less then Cottonelle Ultra Comfortcare. It is a fine toilet paper, with more room for improvement.
3. Cottonelle Cleancare
Cost: 0.58/count
This is the toilet paper that I managed to use for the longest since out of my first sample of toilet papers it turned out to work the best. Lasts about the same as Charmin Ultra Strong, though it is a bit stronger but more ripply.
Overall all these are fine to use, hopefully at least one of them will improve to meet my expectations properly and make me really happy and I will consume since then till the rest of my stay that specific one. For now definitely recommend Cottonelle Ultra ComfortCare, but will update if my opinion changes.
Images in this review
Top reviews from other countries
camille
very soft !
Reviewed in Canada on February 4, 2024Size: 1 roll (Pack of 12)Verified Purchase
Amazon Customer
Strong yet soft
Reviewed in Canada on January 31, 2022Size: 36 roll (Pack of 1)Verified Purchase
Amazon Customer
Good quality, good price, good for septic systems
Reviewed in Canada on September 28, 2020Size: 3408 Count (Pack of 1)Verified Purchase
Ron
Best bang for your buck
Reviewed in Canada on February 6, 2017Size: 1 roll (Pack of 12)Verified Purchase
Diana T
Good price, great product.
Reviewed in Canada on May 29, 2017Size: 1 roll (Pack of 12)Verified Purchase
