
Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet or computer – no Kindle device required.
Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.
Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.
Hubris: The Tragedy of War in the Twentieth Century Hardcover – 3 Sept. 2015
- Print length336 pages
- LanguageEnglish
- PublisherW&N
- Publication date3 Sept. 2015
- Dimensions15.9 x 3.1 x 24.2 cm
- ISBN-100297867628
- ISBN-13978-0297867623
Popular titles by this author
Product description
Review
The case against the awful consequences of military hubris is not hard to make. But Sir Alistair makes it with erudition and eloquence....his narrative is never dull; his judgements are informed by a weary understanding of human folly. This is a book that any political leader contemplating military action should read. (THE ECONOMIST)
Alistair Horne's Hubris (Weidenfeld, £25) provides a penetrating study of six critically important battles of the second world war, each one illustrating how the sin of pride brings disaster on those who indulge in it. It is difficult to know whether to admire more the author's mastery of his subject or his literary skills. (Philip Ziegler THE SPECTATOR, Books of the Year 2015)
Horne is always readable and he has a keen eye for sometimes overlooked connections. One need not agree with Alistair Horne's choice of his analysis to welcome a thought-provoking contribution to an old historical theme. (Ian F. W. Beckett TIMES LITERARY SUPPLEMENT)
I can think of no one better to tackle the daunting subject of hubris and the punishments that so often follow than Alistair Horne. He brings the necessary wisdom, vast knowledge of the past and understanding of human nature to show the effects of hubris in modern warfare. In his masterly and confident hands, we are shown how victory whether that of the Japanese navy at Tsushima in 1905 or General MacArthur's in the first stages of the Korean War leads all too commonly to complacency and then disaster. A wonderful read. (Margaret MacMillan)
This is Alistair Horne's 25th book and it is filled with the insights that can come only from a lifetime of studying war. Hubris is his title and his leitmotif - more precisely, the over-confidence that so often leads to military disaster. But there is no hubris in the author himself, who approaches the challenges of writing about Oriental conflicts with a due humility, as well as his customary literary skill (Niall Ferguson)
In this well written, deeply researched, and persuasively argued book, Horne, the venerable British military historian, looks at six critical battles of the 20th century, focusing on what he argues is a constant that links all of them: the hubristic arrogance exhibited by those on the losing end. In military history, the word hubris is most often used to explain one of the primary flaws of American Vietnam War policymakers, but Horne looks across the 50 years that preceded that engagement ... Horne convincingly argues that "infection by hubris" is alive and well today, and he rounds out the work by discussing ways that 21st-century leaders can work to avoid it (PUBLISHERS WEEKLY (USA))
the book is a dramatic, colourful and stylishly written history. A very enjoyable and enjoyable volume. (WARSHIP WORLD)
Book Description
About the Author
Product details
- Publisher : W&N (3 Sept. 2015)
- Language : English
- Hardcover : 336 pages
- ISBN-10 : 0297867628
- ISBN-13 : 978-0297867623
- Dimensions : 15.9 x 3.1 x 24.2 cm
- Best Sellers Rank: 1,234,513 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
- 34,056 in World History (Books)
- 342,827 in Society, Politics & Philosophy
- Customer reviews:
About the author

Discover more of the author’s books, see similar authors, read author blogs and more
Customer reviews
Customer Reviews, including Product Star Ratings, help customers to learn more about the product and decide whether it is the right product for them.
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyses reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Learn more how customers reviews work on Amazon-
Top reviews
Top reviews from United Kingdom
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
Alistair Horne writes so effectively and this subject like that other must read classic about the horror of Verdun - The Price of Glory ,have just got to be read.
Marvellous stuff...
Top reviews from other countries



トピックは6つで、日本海海戦、ノモンハン、モスクワ攻防戦、ミッドウェイ、朝鮮戦争、そしてディエンビエンフーです。6つのうち3つが日本に関わるものですが、全体の3分の1が日本海海戦に割かれており、最後の2章はエピローグ的な扱いなので、実質上、近代日本の軍事的冒険について書かれた本と言えるでしょう。
著者のメッセージは明快で、「敵を見下すと痛い目に遭う」。当たり前ですが、いかに将軍や政治家、一般兵士までが「過去の成功による驕り」にとらわれるかを描いています。
文体は魅力的で、ついつい読みふけってしまいます。とくに日本海海戦、ミッドウェイ海戦については、戦闘開始のあたりでは(結果を知っていても)手に汗を握ります。
ただ、著者は(当たり前ですが)英語の文献に頼って書いており(しかもかなり古い物も含まれるようで)、近代日本史に関心のある人にはあまりエキサイティングではないかもしれません。やや古くさい見解や、疑問符の湧く箇所がいくつもありました(南京事件についても、死者30万人という数字をなんの留保もなく記しています)。ですので「研究にもとづく最新の知見」みたいなものを期待するとがっかりします。
ただ、英語圏の読者に日露戦争の歴史的意義や、ノモンハン事件、そして辻政信の存在を知らしめるという点では面白い本だろうと思いました。
全体に、「英国人の(偏った)視点から見た日本」という印象です(けっきょく、皆いくらか偏っているわけなので)。
・日本海海戦では秋山真之の名前は出てこなくて、手柄はただ東郷元帥のものということになっています。
・バルチック艦隊が日本に来るまでの苦難の道のりが丁寧に書かれていて、読んでいてかわいそうになってきます。
・ノモンハン事件について、1939年の夏という決定的な時期に、日本にシベリア攻略を諦めさせることがいかに重要だったかを描いています。このへんも英語圏の読者には驚きかもしれません。ちなみに逮捕されたリヒャルト・ゾルゲが、拷問を受けなかったことを「日本人のほかの場所での残虐性を考えると信じられないことだ」と書いています。
・著者は山本五十六のことを「日本では尊敬されているけど、ちっとも偉大ではない」と冷淡です。
わたしはむしろモスクワ攻防戦やディエンビエンフーのくだりを面白く読みました。
ともあれ、歴史読み物としてはなかなかと思います。

Minor subtraction for errors in details which I spotted. Like American tanks being called Ronsons.
